北大教授张海霞：致IEEE主席的公开信

说实话怕被打

 

北大教授张海霞：致IEEE主席的公开信

4 r- m, y4 v7 M
1 v0 I2 l& b: ^6 p
人工智能学家
1小时前 · 优质科技领域创作者

4 c6 u0 `0 m7 e; {& h" k
张海霞，北京大学，信息科学技术学院，教授，声明原文地址：
+ ^# l* D2 c- m+ k: ]& a9 B- |http://blog.sciencenet.cn/home.php?mod=space&uid=299
; t# z7 `  r/ J# p1 |! l) \8 K
0 j" e1 L) Y2 Y. a$ x6 J【声明】惊闻IEEE下令禁止华为专家参与期刊审稿，这远远超出了一个可以接受学术人的底线，做为IEEE的会员和期刊编委，我不得不必须有自己的态度：我已经申请退出我所在的两个IEEE期刊的编委会，并给IEEE候任主席写了一封公开信，这是我个人的态度，与任何其他组织和个人无关。
, e) O/ y; ^3 u- Y0 ?5 x
( L7 G+ P+ A8 R' v/ d% Y0 `; P9 wDear Prof. Toshio Fukuda (the IEEE President as-elected),
. U8 m( ?  s  t( k) ~. K6 P' g
This is Haixia Zhang from Peking University, as an old friend and senior IEEE member, I am really shocked to hear that IEEE is involved in "US-Huawei Ban" for replacing all reviewers from Huawei, which is far beyond the basic line of Science and Technology which I was trained and am following in my professional career till now.
) I/ m3 T+ x% Z( C" N% n0 Q& b: t, @/ l
# N  J  Q9 ?9 w% z2 ~! s. C  i& P# [I joined IEEE since I were a Ph.D student because it is recognized as an International academic platform in Electronics Engineering relative areas by my colleagues, friends worldwide. During last 20 years, I worked with many scientists like you together in IEEE societies, journals, conferences, events, for example, last year during your election as the first president of IEEE from Asian, because we all believe that IEEE is an international society, not just belong to USA or north America area, its members cover all over the world and everyone has equal right to make it more professional with high efficiency.

: f6 _: U/ _0 cBut, today, this message from IEEE for “replacing all reviewers from Huawei in IEEE journals” is challenging my professional integrity. I have to say that, As a professor, I AM NOT accept this, therefore, I decided to quit from IEEE NANO and IEEE JEMS editorial board untill one day it comes back to our common professional integrity.
8 j, C4 a! D+ b, h  h3 _. ^
Please pass this letter to IEEE office and responsible officers.
* E- G' M+ B- z+ c/ `# {# N. t
2 L% e# D$ i5 z; r* h8 kLooking for the daylight.
( q( Q3 E9 [5 P+ a0 e
: U/ o, q( C" }7 T8 ^. eHaixia Zhang, Professor, Peking University
; ?7 C2 v. d; K# H# L
May 29th, 2019

Attachment, my email to TNANO, JMEMS editor-in-chief.
" |" [- l4 {$ n: g$ y
4 v5 z4 S  @7 d4 q# ~6 _Dear Prof. Fabrizio Lombardi(the Chief Editor of IEEE TNANO),
, h, @1 k& V1 g
" E# q) F3 u0 x& DDear Prof. Gianluca Piazzai(the Chief Editor of IEEE TNANO),
  o! k. s) Y- W% l% o1 b: K; V" l
This is Haixia Zhang from Peking University, as an associate editor on IEEE NANO board for several years, I am very happy to work with you and other professors world wide in micro-nano field in professional way. Today, I am really regret to hear that IEEE is involved in "US-Huawei Ban" for replacing all reviewers from Huawei, which is far beyond the basic line of Science and Technology which I perfer to follow in my professional career, therefore, I decided to quit from IEEE NANO editorial board untill it come back to professional zone.
4 Y  v0 O$ D3 {5 @6 q/ D8 ~
, X" O" e; ]4 v- B! PAll my bests.

Haixia Zhang, Professor, Peking University
+ ?. R: S9 @% s4 t* j% }% S! H
May 29th,
$ ]+ k- G# H: |( Z0 ^  B

 

 

山的那外山

 

这英文也不懂啊

 

 

说实话怕被打

 

附图
! u# e1 b, n/ x0 Y" |
" N9 {+ x# U: H8 U% V: J

5 s* S( @; |6 Y- _& a" F

 

 

说实话怕被打

 

部分翻译

 

 

说实话怕被打

 

国际电气学术组织IEEE禁止华为员工参与旗下杂志编审
( ?8 s8 B4 z0 ?

9 g! v3 [4 `/ ^+ N" v
新京报
1小时前 · 新京报官方账号
新京报快讯（记者 冯琪）5月29日，一则“IEEE下令清理华为系审稿人”的消息登上热搜。近日，IEEE（Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers，国际电气与电子工程师协会）发布的一则禁令邮件被曝光，邮件中禁止华为员工作为旗下期刊杂志的编辑和审稿人。
" Z3 d3 O. W* g. G9 |6 b6 Z( B
7 J+ u8 B9 t5 B2 O据悉，IEEE为全球性非营利性跨国学术组织，致力于电子、电气、计算机、通信等领域的科研，具有较大影响力；而华为有多位研究人员在该机构担任学术职务。
7 @: j* |$ L& u6 A
( _: N4 f3 b! q2 p- f/ T- t9 I曝光的邮件中显示，由于美国商务部将华为列入黑名单，IEEE声明“根据IEEE FAQ文档第12项，我们不能使用华为员工作为期刊的同行评审过程的审稿人或编辑。”并声称，可以让华为员工留在编辑委员会，只是不能处理任何文件，直到华为从商务部黑名单中删除。
  ^; i6 t9 H. a2 C8 c+ Z
4 X0 }) r5 F6 Q9 j% p; m% f! D6 A邮件中写道：“我们别无选择，只能遵守这些新规定，强烈建议您执行以下程序：如果您的编辑委员会中有华为的编辑，请首先通知他们，并向他们解释情况。一旦您通知了这些编辑，请向所有编辑发送电子邮件，并告知他们不能再使用华为员工作为审稿人。如果目前有论文被分配给华为员工，请建议他们寻找替代者。请编辑向华为审核人员解释情况。”
: |+ S3 c! A% \9 \7 M/ u
* e4 v1 v* q9 F) z( }5 @消息曝出后，不少微博网友直呼“说好的科学无国界呢？”该事件在学术圈也引发讨论，南京大学教授周志华在朋友圈发布评论称 “赤裸裸地干涉学术”。
6 n. c5 y6 u: U2 o0 f; I
记者了解到，IEEE于1963年由AIEE（美国电气工程师学会）和IRE（美国无线电工程师学会）合并成立。旗下有《IEEE Transaction》《IEEE Magazine》等多种期刊杂志。该机构还曾在南方科技大学、郑州大学等国内近30所大学成立学生分会。曾有媒体报道，其会员人数超过40万人，遍布160多个国家，在计算机工程、生物医学工程等多个领域制定了900多个行业标准。

# ^$ O! B0 I" r  V  p这就是张教授为什么写那封信
' e  W- B5 k; \+ j0 t. M3 M5 |- E

 

 

你逢场作戏

 

看不懂